A History by Judge (work in progress)

 This thread will hopefully turn into a complete list of all major mma judges and their scores in each fight. I've had a very hard time finding any scores so I felt like one place to find all information would be very useful. 



I feel judges should be held accountable to the scores they make and too often people say "that 30-27 decision was ridiculous" as opposed to "that Tony Weeks decision was crazy". It's time to put a name to the scores so I will be spending this weekend trying to compile all the info.



I am going make a few more posts to make sure that if I run over the allowed characters per post, they will all be together at the front of this thread. Hopefully some one can eventually make a site about this and this thread will become obsolete, but until then I intend to maintain this through each major event.



I was originally going to just do this for me, but I might as well post it for all to see.

 

Abe Belardo:

Date Show Fighters Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
Score
           



   

 Adalaide Byrd:




























































Date Show Fighters Decision  Fightmetric 

(10 pt must) 
 Score 
2/6/10 UFC

109
Maia

vs

Miller
Maia

UD
NA 30-27

Maia
2/6/10 UFC

109
Danzig

vs

Buchholz
Danzig

UD
NA 29-28

Danzig
2/6/10 UFC

109
Nover

vs

Emerson
Emerson

UD
NA 29-28

Emerson
1/2/10 UFC

108
Evans

vs

Silva
Evans

UD
Evans

(draw)
29-28

Evans
 12/5/09 TUF 10

Finale 
Madsen

vs

Wren 
Madsen

SD 
NA 30-27

Madsen 
           

 

   


Jeff Collins:





























 Date Show Fighters Decision   Fightmetric 

(10 PT Must)
 Score
 11/21/09 UFC 106   Thiago

vs

Volkmann
Thiago

UD 
NA  30-27

Thiago
 11/21/09 UFC 106  Sadollah

vs

Baroni 
Sadollah

UD 
NA  

30-27

Sadollah 


 


  


Douglas Crosby:


 














































 Date Show Fighters Decision   Fightmetric 

(10 PT Must)
 Score 
 2/6/10 UFC 109   Marquardt

Vs

Sonnen
 Sonnen

UD
Sonnen

(29-28)
 30-27

Sonnen
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Maia

Vs

Miller 
 Maia

UD
NA 29-28

Maia 
2/6/10 UFC 109 Guillard

vs

Torres
Guillard

UD
NA 29-28 Guillard
2/6/10 UFC 109 Hague

vs

Tuchscherer
Tucscherer

MD
NA 28-28

Draw




          

 


 


Sal D'Amato:






























 Date  Show  Fighters Decision    Fightmetric 

(10 PT Must)
Score 
 1/2/10 UFC 108  Lauzon

vs

Stout 
Stout

UD 
NA 27-30

Stout 
 12/5/09 TUF 10

Finale 
 Madsen

vs

Wren
Madsen

SD 
NA 29-28

Wren 


 


   


Lester Griffin:

 Date Show Fighters   Decision   Fightmetric 
(10 PT Must)
 Score 
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Marquardt
vs
Sonnen 
Sonnen UD  Sonnen
(29-28)
30-27
Sonnen 
2/6/10  UFC
109 
Maia
vs
Miller 
Maia
UD 
NA 29-28
Maia 
2/6/10 UFC 109 Danzig
vs
Buchholz
Danzig
UD
NA 29-28
Danzig
2/6/10 UFC 109 Stann 
vs
Davis
Davis
UD
NA 27-30
Davis
11/21/09 UFC 106 Ortiz
vs
Griffin
Griffin
SD
Griffin
(29-27)
30-27
Griffin
           













  

Dave Hagen:

 Date Show  Fighters Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
Score
 12/5/09 TUF 10
Finale 
Slice
vs
Alexander 
Slice
UD 
Slice
(30-29)
30-27
Slice 
 12/5/09 TUF 10
Finale 
Stann
vs
Wallace 
Stann
UD 
NA 29-28
Stann 

   


Nelson Hamilton:

Tuchscherer




























 Date Show  Fighters Decision Fightmetric

(10 PT)
 Score 
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Nover

vs

Emerson 
Emerson

UD 
NA 29-28

Emerson 
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Hague

vs

Tuchscherer 
Tuchscherer

MD 
NA 29-28

Tuchscherer 

 

 

Patricia Morse Jarman:

 Date Show  Fighters Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
 Score 
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Guillard
vs
Torres 
 Guillard
UD
NA  29-28
Guillard
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Stann
vs
Davis 
Davis UD  NA 26-30
Davis 
11/21/09 UFC 106 Sadollah
vs
Baroni
Sadollah
UD
NA 30-27
Sadollah
11/21/09 UFC 106 Uno
vs
Camoes
MAJORITY DRAW NA 29-27
Uno


  

Junichiro Kamijo:

 Date Show  Fighters Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
Score
           
           


   


Al Lefkowitz:

 Date Show Fighter  Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
Score
           
           
 
 


Cecil Peoples:

 Date Show  Fighters Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
Score
 1/2/10 UFC
108 
Lauzon
vs
Stout 
Stout
UD 
NA 27-30
Stout 
1/2/10  UFC 108  Oliveira
vs
Gunderson 
Oliveira
UD 
NA 30-27
Oliveira 
12/5/09 TUF 10 Finale Stann
vs
Wallace
Stann
UD
NA 29-28
Stann
           


       

Marcos Rosales:

 Date Show Fighters  Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
 Score 
11/21/09 UFC 106 Ortiz
vs
Griffin
Griffin
SD
Griffin
(29-27)
29-28
Griffin
 11/21/09 UFC 106  Uno
vs
Camoes 
 MAJORITY DRAW NA  28-28
 
           
 

  


Roy Silbert:

 Date Show Fighters  Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
Score
 1/2/10  UFC 108 Evans
vs
Silva 
Evans
UD 
Evans
(29-29)
29-28
Evans 
 1/2/10 UFC 108  Oliveira
vs
Gunderson 
 Oliveira
UD
NA 30-27
Oliveira 
11/21/09 UFC 106 Thiago
vs
Volkmann
Thiago
UD
NA 30-27
Thiago

   

Glenn Trowbridge:

 Date Show Fighters  Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
 Score 
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Danzig
vs
Buchholz 
Danzig UD  NA 29-28
Danzig 
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Stann 
vs
Davis 
Davis
UD 
NA 26-30 
Davis
2/6/10 UFC 109 Hague
vs
Tuchscherer
Tuchscherer
MD
NA 29-28
Tuchscherer
1/2/10 UFC
108
Oliveira
vs
Gunderson
Oliveira
UD
NA 30-27
Oliveira
 12/5/09 TUF 10
Finale 
Slice
vs
Alexander 
Slice
UD 
Slice
(30-29)
29-28
Slice 
12/5/09 TUF 10
Finale
Madsen
vs
Wren
Madsen
SD
NA 29-28
Madsen
11/21/09 UFC 106 Ortiz
vs
Griffin
Griffin
SD
Griffin
(29-27)
29-28
Ortiz
11/21/09 UFC 106 Thiago
vs
Volkmann
Thiago
UD
NA 29-28
Thiago
11/21/09 UFC
106
Uno
vs
Camoes
MAJORITY
DRAW
NA 28-28



      

Tony Weeks:

  
 Date Show  Fighters Decision Fightmetric
(10 PT)
 Score 
 2/6/10  UFC 109  Marquardt
vs
Sonnen
Sonnen
UD 
Sonnen
(29-28)
30-27
Sonnen
 2/6/10 UFC 109  Guillard
vs
Torres 
Guillard
UD 
NA 29-28 Guillard 
2/6/10 UFC 109 Nover
vs
Emerson
Emerson
UD
NA 29-28 Emerson
1/2/10 UFC
108
Evans
vs
Silva
Evans
UD
Evans
(29-29)
29-28
Evans
1/2/10   UFC
108
 Lauzon
vs
Stout
Stout
UD 
NA 26-30
Stout 
12/5/10  TUF 10
Finale 
Slice
vs
Alexander 
Slice
UD 
Slice
(30-29)
29-28
Slice 
12/5/10  TUF 10
Finale 
Stann
vs
Wallace 
Stann
UD 
NA 30-27
Stann 
11/21/09  UFC 106   Sadollah
vs
Baroni
Sadollah
UD 
NA 29-28
Sadollah 
           
           
           
           
           
           
           
           
    

             

Awesome work man keep it up.

 Will work more on this tomorrow.



I can only find the scores through the NSAC website, so I only have Nevada fights. If anyone knows where to find other cards, a link would be greatly appreciated.