Arya Stark (GOT) vs Carl Walsh (Walking Dead)
Who's tougher for starters?
And Who kills who?? 
Arya 
Carl even with half a brain and one eye. He's cold blooded.
HODOR
Weapon load outs are an essential part of this question, OP.
Arya would demolish Carl Grimes. And Carl Walsh too, whoever the fuck that is.
Yeah I think ya have to go no guns which I feel makes Arya the betting Favorite
Lex_o - Yeah I think ya have to go no guns which I feel makes Arya the betting FavoriteNo guns? That's just stupid. Carl is all range.
Depends how far down the series we go (not just tv).
But Aryia.
CHILLITACO -Depends how far down the series we go (not just tv).
But Aryia.
this
book arya takes this with a stick
Not sure bout the no Guns so I think Carl can have Daryl's crossbow its a pretty advance weapon
Arya easily.
Clearly, Willy the Coyote has either read the books, read the "Story of Fire and Ice" wikis, or read some other spoilers, concerning Arya.
Don't know or care who Carl is, Arya is as NBK as Carlos Condit or Woody Harrellson.
Willy the Coyote -Arya before Carl knows she's there.
Arya, without anyone knowing she was ever there.
Arya by Jaqen
Assuming that Carl didnt have a gun, since Arya wouldn't even know what a gun is, she would fuck Carl up. He is mentally tough.. For a kid from the 2000s... Ayra has survived on her own, killed with her hands, and more if you read the books.
NVM, too spoilery
But it wouldn't matter if Carl had a gun or not.
Arya
The Stark bitch, and it ain't close.