Tons - Agreed 100 percent. A former dominant all time great champ deserves an immediate rematch after that type of close loss.
Agreed. A rematch for the title is the most logical next fight for BJ.
HBL, im starting you like you brah!
Edgar should have to defend against Maynard.
Winner fights Penn.
Anything else is b.s.
shanoknowsmma - Edgar should have to defend against Maynard.
Winner fights Penn.
Anything else is b.s.
Penn should fight the #2 contender on the same card as Edgar/Maynard.
You know, the funny thing about this bullshit decision is that it doesn't bother me one bit. It's not like when Shogun was jobbed against Machida, because I wasn't sure he would be able to pull it off twice and would never get the credit for beating him.
In this case, I know for a fact that if BJ Penn and Frank Edgar ever step in the cage again, BJ Penn will strangle him mercilessly.