Found this thread while searching for something else.
Total bullshit answers. Unless they could prove you did it on purpose, that would absolutely be covered. I've paid out on claims for that exact scenario many times. We've paid out on way dumber ones, like someone dropping a bowling ball on their floor. It cracked a tile, the tile ran continuous throughout the house, so we paid $20k+ because we couldn't maintain a "reasonably uniform appearance" by just replacing the one tile.
It is a scam common in south Florida. We pay and you don't even have to get the repair done. You replace that one tile yourself and keep the rest. Of course, if you ever have another claim they aren't going to pay for the flooring again.
It's rare to see that kind of scam, but in areas where it becomes common, insurance companies drive up rates and treat their customers much worse. I'd say Florida is the worst place for insurance companies and customers. Both sides are used to trying to fuck the other.
But in general, I'd say property insurance is very straight-forward and fraud is rare. Most companies will treat you very well, assuming you understand what your policy covers in the first place.