There's only been a couple of these that I've tried... Sierra Nevade Pale Ale and the Chimay. Mostly foreign beers here, with a few American craft brews.
What do you guys think? Any severe oversights here?
If "coolest" = best, then it's a pretty weak list, to me. I've had 13 of those beers, with the Franziskaner Hefe, Anchor Liberty and Young's Barley Wine being the the best of them.
It isn't very imaginative to be sure. The Anchor Brewing Liberty Ale is nice. Alot of the Imports are pretty standard...although I haven't tried all of them.
This has 2 things in common with most uninformed beer lists I see. 1- The beers are either slightly-upclassed imports (Chimay, Franziskaner), or microbrew beers from the pub around the corner from the author's house that like 3 people have tried. Gives a sense of exclusivity to the list for people who don't know anything. For those of us who do, it just looks stupid. 2- The descriptions are generally poor to fair, like someone read a beer for dummies book and just got drunk.
Actually you are kinda right. It's not anything special but I always seem to end up with some of it in my fridge...it's my go to beer when I can't make up my mind.
The Grolsch Amber is fantastic. If you haven't tried it, you really should. The problem is that the beer store near me only seems to have it in the summer....then I drink twice as much.
I actually think it's a perfect list. It says "coolest beers," not "best beers."
What would make a beer cool? It would be a beer that, when in hand, other people would think you're cool, right? Who is other people? Random people. Most would be uneducated about beer. People who see a 6-pack selling for $8 and think, wow, that must be a high class beer, then they go buy their Bud Light.
When they go to the grocery store to buy beer, what are the most common expensive beers they generally see? That's right.. Grolsch, Chimay, etc... 3/4 of the beer on that list. Keep in mind that the average person has not even tried any of them, so good beer or not, they have a mysterious and "cool" aura.
" The image is just short hand for the qualities the product actually has."
I disagree... Fat Tire, for example, has become wildly popular and very 'cool' to like, judging by the people who drink it religiously, but it's only a mediocre beer at best. Its success a product of fashion and marketing, not quality.