Anyone else feel he won both benson fights?
I also think he'd beat Diaz and Melendez if he was champ at the time.
Still should me champ... But that's why you never leave it to the judges 
He won the second fight against Henderson without a doubt. In my opinion he also edged out the Aldo fight
Lost the first one, won the second, and lost to Aldo. 
I really enjoy watching Frankie fight. Even though some people give him shit for not finishing, you can't say he doesn't bring it each and every round. His footwork, boxing, and desire to win is just a bad ass things to watch. IMO
Lost the first won the second and lost to Aldo. Hope mendes gets by clay so these to can finally fight.
the only frank edgar desicion I don't agree with was the draw against maynard
I thought Frankie beat Aldo and Benson the second time. The first fight's a toss up.
Thuglife13 - Had he not committed the robbery on B.J. Penn in their first fight, he wouldn't have gotten his 6 title fights in a row...
correct
but i blame the judges, not frankie
MMAlurk -Edgar is one of my favorite fighters to watch. He always gives it everything he has.
I feel the same way. He is one of my favorites
ChipW -A favorite of mine as wellMMAlurk -Edgar is one of my favorite fighters to watch. He always gives it everything he has.
I feel the same way. He is one of my favorites
tough little bastard-don't mess with those Toms River cats, they'll scratch your eyes out
MMA Lives Here - Decisively beaten by Benson in their first fight and decisively beaten by Aldo.This.
I thought he won the rematch, but lost the first fight. He was gifted a win in the first fight with BJ, but clearly beat him in the rematch. The decision loss to Aldo was also razor thin. Edgar lives by the sword (close decisions) and dies by it.