Grand Theft Auto 5 vs. Elder Scrolls 5 Skyrim

I was deep in the heart of Skyrim upon the release of GTAV and had to pull it out of my 360 to switch gears. I haven't played enough yet to offer my opinion but who do you think does a better open world game to suit your tastes? I find myself comparing them throughout my play. Phone Post

APPLES AND ORANGES IMO.



GTA'S WORLD HAS FAR BETTER DETAIL AND WAY MORE REALISTIC. SKYRIM IS MORE IMMERSIVE IN TERMS OF SPEAKING WITH EVERYONE AND HAVING MORE PERSONAL CONVERSATIONS.

GTA 5 is probably the greatest game ever made.

BIGWHITESEXY - APPLES AND ORANGES IMO.



GTA'S WORLD HAS FAR BETTER DETAIL AND WAY MORE REALISTIC. SKYRIM IS MORE IMMERSIVE IN TERMS OF SPEAKING WITH EVERYONE AND HAVING MORE PERSONAL CONVERSATIONS.

How would you know anything about apples and oranges?

Even if you considered it apples and oranges, which it's not, and I figured some might say, you can still say whether you prefer the apple or the orange right? I just think they have differences is all, not uncomparable. Both are trying to create an immersive open world. Who does the better job? Phone Post

Skyrim.

Haven't played gta 5, but I always preferred elder scrolls/fallout games to gta. It's the rpg elements I like. Phone Post 3.0

Definitely miss being able to converse with the other people. But like that I can annihilate people without worrying about messing up the world or quests. People talk shit in Skyrim and I have to take it. People talk shit in gta and they get smoked. Phone Post

lol the best part of conversations in Skyrim is when the guards talk down to you. HEY BITCH I KILLED DRAGONS!!! hahahaha

Can you take control of gang territory like in San Andreas? I liked that aspect back in the olden days. Phone Post

Anyone? Phone Post

PUBLIC's_bsc_in_my_bloodyfluid - 
BIGWHITESEXY - APPLES AND ORANGES IMO.



GTA'S WORLD HAS FAR BETTER DETAIL AND WAY MORE REALISTIC. SKYRIM IS MORE IMMERSIVE IN TERMS OF SPEAKING WITH EVERYONE AND HAVING MORE PERSONAL CONVERSATIONS.

How would you know anything about apples and oranges?

THAT MADE ME LOL YOU SON OF A FUCK

wasabi - 

Definitely miss being able to converse with the other people. But like that I can annihilate people without worrying about messing up the world or quests. People talk shit in Skyrim and I have to take it. People talk shit in gta and they get smoked. Phone Post


This is why I think GTA V is better. I don't have time for people to talk to me and piss me off. I got planes to steal, cars to jack, money to make, drugs to do, and strippers to get lap dances from. If don't like you in the game, your gonna get shot mutha fucka!!!

I just want bethesda to see gta v then raise the bar with Fallout 4 and Elder Scrolls 6 Phone Post

If Bethesda did a modern day game with guns and cars, with their level of depth it would be unreal. With the deeper rpg elements. Phone Post

Not quite the poll numbers I hoped for.
If only I could make a poll thread. Phone Post

Only thing I don't like about GTA is what Skyrim does great. Talking to people, tangible rewards for exploring, and being able to go in every building. Phone Post 3.0

TANK BROS - I just want bethesda to see gta v then raise the bar with Fallout 4 and Elder Scrolls 6 Phone Post
I just want Fallout 4 period. Phone Post 3.0

awilson82 - Only thing I don't like about GTA is what Skyrim does great. Talking to people, tangible rewards for exploring, and being able to go in every building. Phone Post 3.0

Yep Phone Post

I found Skyrim too repetitive. Those dwarven ruins for instance, very long and mundane. It's a completionists nightmare. And for someone who's a loot whore like myself that game can give you a brain aneurysm. The amount of hours I wasted walking super slowly because I didn't want to give up my precious loot would be embarassing to see.