Is Jose Aldo in the discussion for #1 p4p?

Underground
1

 What do you think UG? I go with yes.

2

Not unless he moves up to beat Edgar. Until then he'll always be behind Bones and AS. Orrrrr, he could just wait for those guys to lose.

3

How is he behind Bones? Bones has only defended his title twice...

4

no way. Hasnt fought nor beaten nearly the calibur of guys that other top pfp fighters have.

There simply might not be enough talent at 145 for Aldo to be recognized as the best pfp. Sure, he looks great against everyone he fights, but the majority of fans will argue that most of them were nobodies.

5

no 2 behind AS

6

BrockbackMountain - no 2 behind AS


how the FUCK is he ahead of GSP ? Look, Aldo is great but he's been fighting top 10 guys for what, the last 2+ years? GSP has been doing it for the better part of 7 years. Nice try tho.

7

Always Phone Post

8

3 in my opinion. No one has come close to beating him since he started in WEC

9

ThreadRuiner - 
BrockbackMountain - no 2 behind AS


how the FUCK is he ahead of GSP ? Look, Aldo is great but he's been fighting top 10 guys for what, the last 2+ years? GSP has been doing it for the better part of 7 years. Nice try tho.



GSP Y U NO FINSH FIGHTS?

10
  1. Silva
  2. GSP
  3. Aldo
  4. Jones
11
ThreadRuiner -
BrockbackMountain - no 2 behind AS


how the FUCK is he ahead of GSP ? Look, Aldo is great but he's been fighting top 10 guys for what, the last 2+ years? GSP has been doing it for the better part of 7 years. Nice try tho.

Gsp? Lol he's 4 maybe 5. We're discussing if Aldo is ahead of silva and bones. Where did u get gsp out of this thread? Phone Post

12

Silva is #1 hands down.

Jon Jones and José Aldo is a toss up for #2 and #3.

Junior and GSP for #4 and #5. Phone Post

13

I dont see how Jones is in the mix for p4p. Obviously he'll be there one day but beating a few guys this year that other ppl in the UFC have already beat doesn't give him p4p status. Phone Post

14

I think i confused myself with that post I'm thinking of all time not current, I guess for current p4p Jones is in there. Phone Post

15

I got Aldo at 4 in my personal PFP rankings.

16

ThreadRuiner - 
BrockbackMountain - no 2 behind AS


how the F*** is he ahead of GSP ? Look, Aldo is great but he's been fighting top 10 guys for what, the last 2+ years? GSP has been doing it for the better part of 7 years. Nice try tho.

chill out dude. p4p is the most opinion based thing in the sport. I think Silva is clearly number one, 2-4 are pretty debatable between Bones, Aldo and GSP. I'd go Aldo 2 but its like I'm offended with anybody that disagrees with me