mjm345 - I think belt testing is a must (at least for blue belt). There are plenty of guys who roll like monsters, but can't demonstrate a proper shrimp or armbar.
Insctructors will watch you over a period of time and make their decision based on what they see.
If somoene doesn't know how to shrimp then they will not be able to escape from the bottom, therefore they will not get their blue belt.
renatopenha - Congrats PittBJJ. If you did that well at your tourney, and your instructor is asking you to test, that's two signs that you're ready and will be fine.Re: testingI'm a three stripe purple belt, and have never been tested. I feel like I might fail a Roy Harris blue belt test, though. Those videos are seriously intimidating. I've always concentrated on base and balance and getting good at a few basic techniques. ie I've worked really hard on recovering guard and getting to my knees from under sidemount, but I don't have four reversals from there. I wonder at how many schools I wouldn't be a "knowledge" purple belt, or even blue.
^Lol sounds like me.
We test blue belts now, it is as much a ceremony as a test. They have to demonstrate a lot of techniques than roll with a number of people their level and above. They are dead at the end, but I think they appreciate their belt when it is done.