Post 'brawl' ..who'd you discipline?

Obviously something has to happen after what went on in the cage...... if you were in Coker's shoes and the athletic commissions shoes, what fines and/or disciplinary actions would you hand out?


I personally would suspend both Diaz brothers for a min of 1 year as the athletic commission and levy a 25k fine....In Coker's shoes and the athletic commissions shoes, I would revoke the corners licenses of each corner man involved in the melee/brawl whom was throwing punches/kicks and what not and fine them each 5k.

I dont think shields should face any fine/suspension since he only pushed Mayhem, who did butt in on his interview. Mayhem should get a 5-10k fine for being involved in the brawl, even in a defensive mode, but no suspension.


what say you?

 Shields threw 2 punches and was then dragged away.. and then realised he'd just done that on national telivision, cue pic of him looking up at the big screen when being separated from the fray.

I dunno, but what about the guy who butts in on an interview that has nothing to do with him?

i felt kinda bad for shields..he seemed pretty emotional afterwards. its not like he asked for the whole thing to happen, im sure he was still fired up in primal mode seeing as how he just finished his fight. i think after the whole thing went down he realized he just made a huge mistake.


mayhem..not much to say. horrible, horrible timing..he didnt really ask for that to happen though lol. if i were coker i wouldnt really hold him responsible. id give him a scolding but thats about it (thankfully mauro took care of that for us ;D)

i think most punishment should just be directed towards gil and the cornermen..they were the ones tryin to brutalize mayhem. suspension sounds good to me..fining them..i dunno about that. getting those clowns outta there and preventing these kinda things is a must.

No one should be suspended.

Mayhem went in there to be a dickhead and he succeeded. Little did he know he was crashing the wrong party.

KimuraCrunch - I dunno, but what about the guy who butts in on an interview that has nothing to do with him?


yes he was out of place and it wasnt very tactful.... but it was a way to stay in the spotlight and create a buzz about a rematch..... is that a crime? no


but getting attacked by 5 guys at once was def not a fair result.

just cuz someones a dick doesnt give you the right to fuckin pounce on them like a pack of mongoloid werewolves. there has to be some sort of punishment for that ish, regardless if anyone thinks its just or unjust. gotta make an example outta those fools

Mc6pack -  Shields threw 2 punches and was then dragged away.. and then realised he'd just done that on national telivision, cue pic of him looking up at the big screen when being separated from the fray.


  

---------------     OOOOPS    ---------------------

 Let's face it.



Miller is a clown, everyone knows it. He was asking for trouble all week, throwing his shirt on the ring girl, thunder stealing, being Mayhem.



But to have a " champion" jump in on a gang beatdown was just horrible.He should be fined. Diaz should be suspended and Melendez should be fined as well.



I would expect that in the ghetto, but on national tv?



C'mon.

The biggest problem is that suspending anyone puts you at odds with one or more of your biggest stars. Maybe blame it on the ref or something ridiculous lol.

i dont think anyone should label shields just yet


he's a good guy and you can tell he's making an effort to be a good role model for ironically guys a lot like the ones he trains with






shit happens

LOL, Shields is the one that changed the situation from awkward to physical altercation.

Yes Mayhem got into his personal space, but Shields pushed him into a banner and as Melendez tried to move/push Mayhem away, Shields started throwing.

I blame Team Cesar Gracie. Mayhem would have just looked like a dick if they blew it off. Luckly Mayhem is friends with quest or he would have taken more damage imo.

tonight made me completely forget about that ^


lol anderson must be pissed about that

 fire the effn cbs producer who actually cut away and breaked for all that time...the post-fight fight was clutch and cbs missed fuckin gold by not filming...everywhere else TV cameras, cell phone cameras, police car cameras keep rolling...but on cbs? gentlemen, gentlemen, we're on national television....  

Coker

 1. Team CG definitely escalated the situation and should be dealt with.



2. I don't believe Mayhem was sent in by Strikeforce; if he was, Strikeforce should be dealt with for leaving him unescorted and allowing him to completely detract from the show with a disrespectful challenge.



3. The commission if they allowed Mayhem to enter the cage uninvited and left him unescorted.



4. Mayhem for sparking the entire situation that was escalated in the same thuggish and low class flavor he started it with.





As with any problem solving, you attack the root.  And LOL @ that being the standard type of challenge we see in MMA.


ROFL at punishing Mayhem

He did something we have seen countless times in the UFC..

Guy wins a big fight, another fighters comes into the ring to build hype

GSP, Rashad, Carwin wtc.. have all done this

Mayhem came in smiling and asked for a rematch and then the retards at CG flipped out

vengence - Obviously something has to happen after what went on in the cage...... if you were in Coker's shoes and the athletic commissions shoes, what fines and/or disciplinary actions would you hand out?


I personally would suspend both Diaz brothers for a min of 1 year as the athletic commission and levy a 25k fine....In Coker's shoes and the athletic commissions shoes, I would revoke the corners licenses of each corner man involved in the melee/brawl whom was throwing punches/kicks and what not and fine them each 5k.

I dont think shields should face any fine/suspension since he only pushed Mayhem, who did butt in on his interview. Mayhem should get a 5-10k fine for being involved in the brawl, even in a defensive mode, but no suspension.


what say you?


Did you miss when Shields went after Mayhem throwing punches?

Mayhem 100%

Got in his face with attitude and tryed to take the limelight in the biggest win of Jakes career.