Randy vs. Fedor

Who would have won when they were both in their primes?

I'm goin with Randy on this one.

Fedor.

The fight I really wanted Cro Cop/Couture Phone Post 3.0

Fedor. Phone Post 3.0

Fedor, regardless of when, IMO.

 

Cindy

 

Randy is from America, and he was in the UFC. That's why I pick Randy. Plus, he held the belt multiple times in 2 weight classes.

UncleChael - Randy is from America, and he was in the UFC. That's why I pick Randy. Plus, he held the belt multiple times in 2 weight classes.

You're some poor troll right?

Fedor wins at any point in his career in any venue under any set of rules

FEDOR!!!!! Phone Post 3.0

I'm not a delusional Fedor fan so it could probably go either way but I'd be inclined to pick Fedor Phone Post 3.0

CindyO - 


Fedor, regardless of when, IMO.



 



Cindy



 


Depends where it takes place. Randy was a master at using the cage to grind out opponents. If Fedor fights the same way he did in Strikeforce, I could easily see an upset.

Fedor. Phone Post 3.0

Fedor via grabbing the ropes, like he did against Lindland. :)

Randy gets mauled and finished at any point, now, then whenever, Obvious troll job, I respect Randy and all but Fedor smashes poor old Handy

This is the same world where Randy Couture was submitted by Valentijn Overeem and Enson Inoue after he was already champion right?

Just wanted to make sure.

UncleChael - Who would have won when they were both in their primes?

I'm goin with Randy on this one.

Fedor would have chewed him up and spat him out inside 1 rd IMO

B_Goetz - Fedor via grabbing the ropes, like he did against Lindland. :)
This Phone Post 3.0

Randy's thing was to break the other fighters will.

Fedor never broke, even after getting pummeled by Bigfoot he answered the bell. But no ref/Dr. would let a fighter go on with sight in only one eye.

GayGuardMooseSaucy - Fedor.

The fight I really wanted Cro Cop/Couture Phone Post 3.0

Agreed, losing that fight was the worst part of the headkick.

Fedor all day Phone Post 3.0

Ring 90/10 Fedor
Cage 60/40 Randy Phone Post 3.0

Fedor would have starched Randy. Phone Post