Shaq retires

Thanks for the 19-seasons, especially '06. 



The most dominating BIG MAN, I have seen. 



Where does Shaq rank all-time? 

If not top 5 hes definately close

 top 10.



There was about a 3 or 4 year span where he was literally unstoppable. No one in the league right now even comes close to how dominant he was.

His jersey will hang from the rafters of Staples Center, as it should. On one hand, I loved the personality he brought to the game, almost child-like in his playfulness. On the other, I wonder how his career would have been different with a better work ethic and competitive drive. Of the dominant big men I have seen play, Shaq and Hakeem are atop the list.

I am glad he retired, it was kind of sad to see him hopping from one team to another in the ring chasing twilight of his career.

Mick Donaldsfan -  He had no tangible skill whatsoever.  Just a very large human who could jump real high.  very boring to watch

Hakeem ate his lunch


TROLOLOLOLO

 There is some truth to what Mick is saying, but lets be real here. 99% of NBA players past and present wouldn't have been in the NBA if they were average in height and athleticism. I'm talking MJ, Magic, Larry, Kobe, Lebron, Dirk, Kareem, Wilt, so on and so forth. Even the smaller players are abnormally quick and athletic. Being tall and athletic is what basketball is all about at it's root, as painful as that may be to believe.



If you knock a guy for being tall and athletic, you really shouldn't be watching the NBA. 

  1. Kareem Abdul-Jabar.
    2. Wilt Chamberlain.
    3. Bill Russell
    4. Hakeem Olajuwon
    5. Shaquille O'Neal

Bill Russell
Kareem
Shaq
Hakeem(though he had the least help among the centers)
Wilt

Mick Donaldsfan - 
HeatleMania12 -  There is some truth to what Mick is saying, but lets be real here. 99% of NBA players past and present wouldn't have been in the NBA if they were average in height and athleticism. I'm talking MJ, Magic, Larry, Kobe, Lebron, Dirk, Kareem, Wilt, so on and so forth. Even the smaller players are abnormally quick and athletic. Being tall and athletic is what basketball is all about at it's root, as painful as that may be to believe.

If you knock a guy for being tall and athletic, you really shouldn't be watching the NBA. <br type="_moz" />

 The players you listed were all SKILLED.  they had post moves or fade away jumpers honed from years of practice and repetition.

Shaq, a man who played basketball his entire life, could not make more than half his free throws.  He shot no sky hooks, he had no jump shot.   His post moves were clumsy and childish.

His entire game was predicated on being the biggest guy on the court.  Back someone down for 5 seconds and dunk.  Or have a skilled player throw the ball up and have him jump real high and dunk.

Hakeem was a much smaller man but RAPED Shaq in the playoffs using a variety of back to the basket moves.  Hakeem was a true player


:/

HeatleMania12 - 99% of NBA players past and present wouldn't have been in the NBA if they were average in height and athleticism.

...holy meaningless quote.

BTW, did you guys know that 99% of NFL players past and present wouldn't have been in the NFL if they were average in size and strength?

Did you guys know that 99% of if the smartest people in the world wouldn't have been the smartest people in the world if they were of average intelligence?

 it's not meaningless, it's a response for bashing a player for being tall and athletic. If you do that, you may as well bash the whole sport. That was my point.

I have failed comprehension (failed to read the thread, in fact).

Shaq had a soft touch around the basket when he needed it. The guy definitely had skills, but he hurt his legacy by playing too long and having a crappy work ethic.

^I agree with that.

He had an amazing career given that and was one of my favorite players. He's definitely top 10. His jersey should be retired by the lakers.

"His post moves were clumsy and childish."

you are such a weak troll. GTFO

quick - Shaq had a soft touch around the basket when he needed it. The guy definitely had skills, but he hurt his legacy by playing too long and having a crappy work ethic.


Quick, being as objective as you can, who do you rank higher as a center: Shaq or David Robinson?

While my answer might blow this thread into a five pager, I would have to pick the Admiral. I have written and erased why that is about eight times now lol. Suffice to say there are a lot of reasons, but ultimately I can forgive the Admiral's shortcomings easier than I can Shaqs. And I know that might not sound like much of an answer, but if I get some time later I will try and elaborate.

quick - While my answer might blow this thread into a five pager, I would have to pick the Admiral. I have written and erased why that is about eight times now lol. Suffice to say there are a lot of reasons, but ultimately I can forgive the Admiral's shortcomings easier than I can Shaqs. And I know that might not sound like much of an answer, but if I get some time later I will try and elaborate.


Ya I think Mark Jackson is better then Jason Kidd. If I get some time later I might elaborate

 I think Shaq was the best big since Moses. I love guys like Robinson, Hakeem, Ewing and others, but Shaq was just better. Not nearly as skilled, but still better.