Shouldn't Rothwell's win over Vera be overturned?

Since Rothwell pissed hot, shouldn't his win over Vera be overturned? Why hasn't this happened yet?

SuPeRkEwL ELECTRIC bleu - Since Rothwell pissed hot, shouldn't his win over Vera be overturned? Why hasn't this happened yet?

No adverse action was taken by the ac so the win wasn't overturned. Phone Post

AC just gave him a warning lol. "Oh your PEDs gave you enough of a testosterone boost that it was illegal! It's okay though just don't do it again." Phone Post

TOAO - 

Should be dq Phone Post



that would give Vera a win for no reason, it's a classic NC situation if the Commission did what hey were supposed to

Somebody who edits wiki changed it to no contest when the news broke, but that was careless.

No where did it say ever that he it was overturned.

I don't really think the win should be overturned but I am all dogs a stood fine IEEE something asking those lines you know what I mean.

Although, I really think beyond on testosterone represent really hurts a fighters cricket. Phone Post

English motherfuckers, do you speak it?

not overturned because the legislation that empowers the AC to sanction MMA does't include provisions allowing decisions to be reversed.

SuPeRkEwL ELECTRIC bleu - Since Rothwell pissed hot, shouldn't his win over Vera be overturned? Why hasn't this happened yet?


I looked at this before and agree that under Wisconsin law it appears this should be a no contest. Here's the breakdown:



SPS 196.03(1) reads as follows “Mixed martial arts contestants may not engage in the personal use of drugs, including all anabolic steroids or controlled substances, pursuant to s. 444.095 (3) (c), Stats., while participating in a bout, except when prescribed, dispensed or administered by a licensed physician or dentist for a legitimate medical condition.”



Apparently the WDSPS was satisfied that Rothwell suffered from a “legitimate medical condition” and granted a TUE for TRT.  Like all exemptions, this TUE is not a free for all and the commission set upper limits.   Rothwell’s results were reportedly above the acceptable range.  It is hard to appreciate how having limits higher than he was cleared for does not put Rothwell in violation of this section.   Accepting there is a violation of 196.03(1) you next look at the remedies.


Failed Drug tests result in mandatory discipline under Wisconsin law with 196.03(9) reading as follows “If laboratory testing of a contestant’s specimen test positive for any alcohol, drug, controlled substance, anabolic steroids or illegal enhancement substances, the contestant shall be disciplined.“



In addition to mandatory discipline (which includes the possibility of more than a mere letter, but also  suspensions under 196.01(1)), the section goes on to note that the bout should be changed to a no contest with the section going on to require the following:


“A contestant who is disciplined and who was the winner of a contest shall be disqualified and the decision shall be changed to no contest. The results of a contest shall remain unchanged if a contestant who is disciplined was the loser of the contest.”.

Has there been any comments from Veras side? Phone Post

Anderson got KTFO - I don't really think the win should be overturned but I am all dogs a stood fine IEEE something asking those lines you know what I mean.

Although, I really think beyond on testosterone represent really hurts a fighters cricket. Phone Post
wat Phone Post 3.0

SuPeRkEwL ELECTRIC bleu - Since Rothwell pissed hot, shouldn't his win over Vera be overturned? Why hasn't this happened yet?
Hi Brendan, Phone Post 3.0

mose - not overturned because the legislation that empowers the AC to sanction MMA does't include provisions allowing decisions to be reversed.

If the legislation is silent on appealing the decision then the final administrative decision can be challenged through judicial review.

http://statutes.laws.com/wisconsin/227/227.52 Phone Post 3.0

Shouldnt have been suspended at all Phone Post 3.0

Why shouldn't he be suspended if he violated the rules? Phone Post 3.0

Anderson got KTFO - I don't really think the win should be overturned but I am all dogs a stood fine IEEE something asking those lines you know what I mean.

Although, I really think beyond on testosterone represent really hurts a fighters cricket. Phone Post

Well that was coherent, made me smile though Phone Post

reminds me of the time royce was busted for nandralone

they didnt take away his bs "win" over saku

 

 

http://www.mmafighting.com/2007/06/19/former-ufc-champion-royce-gracies-nandrolone-levels-off-the-cha