SurferFL - and Michgan241. Don't argue just to argue. If you are happy with the state of MMA reporters than that is fine by me, but don't play devils advocate just to be a jackass.
i dont think mma reporters are good or that im happy with their current state, but i dont think rolling around on the mat is going to change them running stories they havnt properly vetted though.
Matthew S - Theres no way most of those guys covering those sports have played it at a competitive level. Maybe little league or maybe a few years in high school.
You sir are correct. I never said competitive level. I just asking for them to sample the sport. Touch a wrestling mat. Do something to learn about this sport we love.
SurferFL - and Michgan241. Don't argue just to argue. If you are happy with the state of MMA reporters than that is fine by me, but don't play devils advocate just to be a jackass.
i dont think mma reporters are good or that im happy with their current state, but i dont think rolling around on the mat is going to change them running stories they havnt properly vetted though.
I can agree with that. I like to think that mat time won't hurt their reporting.
Idventure to say most Journalists on ESPN have a degree in broadcasting or journalism, however I doubt any of the MMA journalists (LOL At calling any of them journalists) have a degree in journalism. Just becasue you can write shit on a website doesn't make you a journalist it makes you a blogger, so I laugh every time Loretta calls herself a journalist. Shes just a fucking blogger like all the other mma bloggers. She may have a degree but I guarentee you it isnt in journalism.
The majority having not actually attended credited journalism schools and therefore having only basic knowledge on how to compose an article may or may not also be a factor. There are some good journalists...but a lot of weak ones as well.
I have written over 40 mma columns about our local fighters the past 3 years. I watch the fighters train and don't want any part of it, I'm old and broken. I do train mma with my 13 old son(thats more my level). I write for the newspaper as a hobby, its a way I can contribute to the world of mma. I do study and learn all I can about the sport by watching the fighters train and asking questions. I do confirm the info by asking the fighters, watching the fights, talking to the promoters. no journalism degree, PE degree and I'm not a decent writer!!! I hate writing, I rather talk person, its just a way for me to contribute to the sport. mike www.highdesertmma.com
totalwreckage - Idventure to say most Journalists on ESPN have a degree in broadcasting or journalism, however I doubt any of the MMA journalists (LOL At calling any of them journalists) have a degree in journalism. Just becasue you can write shit on a website doesn't make you a journalist it makes you a blogger, so I laugh every time Loretta calls herself a journalist. Shes just a fucking blogger like all the other mma bloggers. She may have a degree but I guarentee you it isnt in journalism.
SurferFL - How can you report on something you've never participated in, even remotely?
Most MMA reporters are nerdy douchebags that have (more than likely) been punched AT LEAST once in their lives. Which, using your "John Clayton throwing a football" analogy, means they are just as qualified as him.
The biggest problem with the MMA media isn't that they haven't competed...the problem is that perhaps no other sport has attracted as many amateurs and neophytes to its sport-specific media outlets. Many of the writers working for said outlets lack even rudimentary journalistic training, and the editorial standards under which they work are often shamefully lax.
Today's MMA media is very much like the boxing media of the 1920s: not yet evolved into a legitimate journalistic enterprise. There are some good writers and reporters working the scene, but by and large, the standards lag far behind the mainstream sports world. To be fair, though, when writers from the mainstream sports world delve into MMA, they tend to wear their own lack of experience on their sleeves.
It should be kept in mind that 95% of the MMA writers out there don't get paid for their work so expecting them to have the same qualifications as a guy on ESPN isn't realistic.