Honestly top 5 maybe top 3 IMO he jumped Aldo tonight 
Not on it at all. Because he's not dominant.
Top 3 no. Top 10 definitely.
Silva, GSP, Bones, Aldo, then from there picking from about 5 fighters. Edgar being one of them.
2nd behind GSP
2 deepest divisions are lw and ww therefore they get the nod
mw is the only division in the history of combat sports that doesnt have another top 25 pound for pound fighter besides the title holder. This leaves Anderson on the outside looking in
MMAReview - Not on it at all. Because he's not dominant.
Wha? Beating BJ and Gray very convincingly isn't enough for u?
also he is a natural 145er who is 2-0 against BJ who prefers to fight at 170,thats a 2 weight class difference
IMO it's
1. Anderson
2. GSP
3/4. Frankie/ Bones
5. Aldo
6. Cain (simply bc no defense yet)
Top 3 as the highest and top 5 as the lowest
Not a P4P list...because that terminology IMO doesn't make any sense...but as far as the top champions go...
Anderson (obvious reasons)
Edgar (great skill, great heart, doesn't cut weight but has a lot more to prove with a stacked division)
Bones (Rose up the ranks quickly. The domination of Shogun and his ability to shut down rampage easily makes him 3rd)
GSP (He has stacked tons of wins together, but has not been in the most exciting of fights. I think he fights "not to lose" more than he tries to go out and finish)
Cain (A bit over-hyped IMO. He's definately one of the best heavyweights, but we will see how he handles JDS and possibly overeem before i move him up)
Aldo (His fights in the UFC have not really impressed me asthetically. He just doesn't appear as domimant as he did in the WEC, otherwise he'd be top 3.)
Dana just said Frankie is #2 p4p
cross3dout - Dana just said Frankie is #2 p4p <img src="/images/phone/apple.png" alt="Phone Post" border="0" style="vertical-align:middle;"/>
p4p is a silly statement, but i agree frankies their 2nd best fighter.
MMAReview - Not on it at all. Because he's not dominant.
He has beaten everyone he ever fought including the widely regarded "best of all time" BJ Penn. Tonight he became the first to KO Maynard, or even defeat him at all in a pro fight.
orcus -MMAReview - Not on it at all. Because he's not dominant.
He has beaten everyone he ever fought including the widely regarded "best of all time" BJ Penn. Tonight he became the first to KO Maynard, or even defeat him at all in a pro fight.
Damn skippy
Ttt
- Anderson
2. GSP
3. Bones
4. Edgar
5. Aldo
Top unwatchable p4p fighter:
Cruz
ILoveWatchingJonesBoneShogun - 2nd behind GSP
2 deepest divisions are lw and ww therefore they get the nod
mw is the only division in the history of combat sports that doesnt have another top 25 pound for pound fighter besides the title holder. This leaves Anderson on the outside looking in
That's exactly my thoughts
Frankie definately deserves to be top 5 p4p. I mean he dominated BJ Penn then came back from getting his ass kicked in the first round and stopped the fight. I don't think there is a fighter today who can match his heart and will to fight.
Anderson = 1
GSP = 2
Frankie = ?
Because you just can't count him out.