Okay lets clear one thing up, I learnt about mma because of Anderson Silva. His 10 title defences are over grown men not midgets. Yes hes had a rough few years, doesnt matter. Anderson>DJ
Besides DJ.....Gsp is the only goat candidate not to ruin his legacy with loses and scandals.
Dc should be a serious contender but JJ muddied those waters.
DJ is far from being the goat. He's fighting in a weight class only women can relate to. How many men do you know that weigh 125 pounds? Take that into account and you'll see how shallow that division really is. If he beats TJ then everything changes though. For now i don't see him as the goat. Specially since he was just a challenger at the 135 division before it became stacked to the max.
Fedor > Ando
Alright, let’s play “Guess who’s troll account”!
I’m going with Steve. When in doubt, Steve.
The G.O.A.T is neither Androgen Silva, nor Mighty Duck.
my goat list
fedor (undefeated at HW for 10 yrs - wft?)
jones(unbeaten, beat big names)
anderson (matrixing dudes)
gsp (dominant, but alot of decisions)
DC (beat everyone but jones)
With that giant asterisks next to his name? Naw. Fuck cheaters
The talent pool in the DJ division is and always has been very shallow. Put that against Jones or Silva and there is no comparison.
Fedora is one of my all time favorites but no way is he goat. It’s Silva then MAYBE gsp only because of Jones dug tests. In reality it’s between Silva and jones. Might mouse shouldn’t even be mentioned in the same sentence as these greats.
BringBackGoldy -Besides DJ.....Gsp is the only goat candidate not to ruin his legacy with loses and scandals.
GSP, i like the guy, but lets face it: he could't finish a fight in 8 years, prime Matrix Silva was knocking people out in Micheal Jackson fashion style. He lost big time to Big Rig Hendrix (we'll never know what kind of corruption system was behind that decision) and wasn't men enough to admit it. Bisping got a title shot just because he's a star, won by a lucky shot, became a very very weak champion, people think GSP deserve that belt.... he would get rape by Romero, Rockold, Jacare, Whittaker etc.... But casual sport bars fans can't see those things. It's an entertainement show now, not a sport anymore.
Prime Silva was an alien, we'll never see that again.