I been thinking about this fight for the last two months, and watching about one fight a day of each of theirs' that I feel could be applicable (that is, something resembling a factor they will face Sept 18).
Here's what I got so far:
1: The first five round of Vargas-ODLH were the PERFECT blueprint of how to close the gap on Oscar and fight him in close. Vargas was doing damned good but then he gassed.
2: Hopkins hasn't been hit with a clean two or three punch combination in years. Single shots, yes, but the guy never gets caught napping. That's pretty amazing. His defense as an aggressor is very simiilar to prime Julio Cesar Chavez, who could move in on a dude and still slip, block, and avoid punches just enough to take the mojo off of them.
3: "Burn rate" is going to be the key driver in this fight, assuming Oscar boxes, Hopkins pressures. Oscar always says he's in great shape before every fight, then makes excuses afterwards. I don't know why, but he does.
Anyways, after the conference call it's obvious that Hopkins is at least SAYING he's going to try and burn DLH out (remember, he never tipped his hand he was gonna box Tito. We all we were sure it'd be a foul-marred slugfest). Hopkins would have no payoff in trying to outbox DLH as an overall strategy, though he could use that in spots like a changeup to keep ODLH off-balance.
Basically, Oscar burned out against Mosley, Tito, didn't vs. Vargas (Fernando kind of burned out instead). You can give him the benefit of the doubt and throw out Sturm, as Oscar seemed like he was banking everything on an early knockout. But basically, Oscar burned out against Mosley with a decent body attack from Shane, not a lot of constant forward pressure -- the reason he burned out vs. Tito was simple, because he moved more than any fighter I've ever seen without fully running (a la Junior Witter-Zab). ODLH-Tito remains the only fight I've ever seen where the first clinch didn't happen until the 10th or 11th round.
That said, Hopkins ALWAYS clinches when he fights boxers. He ALWAYS throws in the rough stuff. He ALWAYS forces fights on his terms. Oscar can't hurt him outside of a perfect punch, and is gonna have to be using his legs like a motherfucker if he wants to flit in and out. And that's not even guaranteeing he can score effectively without getting hurt.
I give ODLH a lot of props for taking this fight. But Hopkins is mentally ready and has been way more impressive against bigger, stronger, and tougher people (he completely dominated Tito whereas Oscar just folded down the stretch). Picking boxing is a vague gesture, but often it comes to mental toughness, and on that score, Hopkins is the last motherfucker I'd ever doubt. The guy is as tough as anybody in the game, and his whole life is about beating Oscar. I don't know if Oscar can say the same in return.
Hopkins will win this one.