This thread's a bit old but if you happen to read this Doug I'd love to hear your opinion on this proposed judging system: http://www.mixedmartialarts.com/?go=forum_framed.posts&forum=1&thread=1560423&page=1&pc=10
How did he score Silva v Maia?
Insulting Doug on this thread will not encourage him to come here and explain. Please show some respect regardless of your feelings on the score he gave.
He wont post here again
unfortunately he prob won't after that last scorecard...i'd like him to come here and basically admit he fucked up and apologize.
officedrone23 - Sorry, I have standards. When you score a fight as ineptly as "superjudge" scored Penn vs. Edgar the best I can do is not give him a dirty sanchez.
Relax and let him give a response before you throw insults around.
JoshMitola -officedrone23 - Sorry, I have standards. When you score a fight as ineptly as "superjudge" scored Penn vs. Edgar the best I can do is not give him a dirty sanchez.
Relax and let him give a response before you throw insults around.
Exactly. I'd rather have him post and there be spirited debate rather than just insulting until he decides NOT to come and make any comment.
round 1 bj lands 94, franky 34
r2 bj lands 110, edgar 28
r3 bj lands 55, edgar 43
bj has 3 rounds, and the fight, in the bag here
r4 bj lands 57, edgar 55
r5 bj lands 63, edgar 96
edgar won round 5 and thats all.
http://www.fightmetric.com/fights/Edgar-Penn.html
Lets Hear it "superjudge"
LMAO
TTT
ranier wolfcastle - round 1 bj lands 94, franky 34I can't for the life of me figure out what those numbers are you posted.
r2 bj lands 110, edgar 28
r3 bj lands 55, edgar 43
bj has 3 rounds, and the fight, in the bag here
r4 bj lands 57, edgar 55
r5 bj lands 63, edgar 96
edgar won round 5 and thats all.
http://www.fightmetric.com/fights/Edgar-Penn.html
^^^ Those are strikes as counted by fightmetric that he posted.
TTT for the "superjudge" to explain himself"
baffling.
I had BJ Penn winning 48-47 , please explain 50-45 Edgar? maybe Superjudge likes to super gamble lol...just kidding, but man that score was weird!!
ranier wolfcastle - round 1 bj lands 94, franky 34
r2 bj lands 110, edgar 28
r3 bj lands 55, edgar 43
bj has 3 rounds, and the fight, in the bag here
r4 bj lands 57, edgar 55
r5 bj lands 63, edgar 96
edgar won round 5 and thats all.
http://www.fightmetric.com/fights/Edgar-Penn.html
You think FightMetric is the deciding factor on who won a fight?
That doesn't quite encompass the scoring criteria.
1 Like
Dude, you are by far the worst judge Ive ever seen. Please stop because you're hurting peoples careers.
the butthurtedness in this thread is strong.
good job on the judging,the internet bj nuthuggers represent .00001 percent of all mma fans,everyone at bw3 last night thought Edgar won the fight,i personally asked about 14 guys who they thought won,the crowd cheered the decision,Rogan and the judges all agreed.BJ's fans will never accept a decision loss,this is why he will never amount to anything more then a 2-1 win loss ratio fighter,its hard to improve when you dont think you have to,blame the judges
Best judge since Cecil Peoples imo..
Brock75thRanger - good job on the judging,the internet bj nuthuggers represent .00001 percent of all mma fans,everyone at bw3 last night thought Edgar won the fight,i personally asked about 14 guys who they thought won,the crowd cheered the decision,Rogan and the judges all agreed.BJ's fans will never accept a decision loss,this is why he will never amount to anything more then a 2-1 win loss ratio fighter,its hard to improve when you dont think you have to,blame the judges
wow. excellent post. Voted UP