I'd say so. Discuss.
GSP
Has he beaten anyone at 185?
Anderson Silva P4P #1.
AnotherTMAguy - Has he beaten anyone at 185?
Anderson Silva P4P #1.
What does that have to do with P4P? I didn't ask where he ranked at 185.
um, GSP wasn't even #2 before tonight.
GSP has loss 2 rounds in the UFC, Anderson just lost 4 in a row. There is no doubt GSP is P4P #1,
Ansari -AnotherTMAguy - Has he beaten anyone at 185?
Anderson Silva P4P #1.
What does that have to do with P4P? I didn't ask where he ranked at 185.
I would say Anderson beating top 5 opponents in 2 weight divisions is more impressive than GSP beating top 5 opponents in 1 weight division.
Yes, Silva was dominated by a journeyman fighter, a good journeyman, but a journeyman nonetheless.
I bet GSP takes the fight now that he sees what a wrestler can do to Silva, which wasn't much of a surprise if you had seen the fight with Chonan.
SteelyRes211 - Yes, Silva was dominated by a journeyman fighter, a good journeyman, but a journeyman nonetheless.
I bet GSP takes the fight now that he sees what a wrestler can do to Silva, which wasn't much of a surprise if you had seen the fight with Chonan.
first ur a MorAn asbout journeyman<br />
but yes GSP would win
AnotherTMAguy -Ansari -AnotherTMAguy - Has he beaten anyone at 185?
Anderson Silva P4P #1.
What does that have to do with P4P? I didn't ask where he ranked at 185.
I would say Anderson beating top 5 opponents in 2 weight divisions is more impressive than GSP beating top 5 opponents in 1 weight division.
P4P is an evaluation of fighters when taking weight of the equation. Try again.
GSP needs to beat an Olympic alternate wrestler, like Anderson just did. This just pushed Anderson further into the lead.
Easily, not even close. Chael impressed the hell out of me tonight, but should have posed about the same threat to Silva as maybe a a fighter like Hardy would to GSP.
GSP wouldn't have lost a round 10-8 to a journeyman.
Ansari -AnotherTMAguy -Ansari -AnotherTMAguy - Has he beaten anyone at 185?
Anderson Silva P4P #1.
What does that have to do with P4P? I didn't ask where he ranked at 185.
I would say Anderson beating top 5 opponents in 2 weight divisions is more impressive than GSP beating top 5 opponents in 1 weight division.
P4P is an evaluation of fighters when taking weight of the equation. Try again.
Taking weight out of the equation is more accurate when a fighter can dominate fighters in 2 weight divisions as opposed to one weight division. Try again.
SteelyRes211 - Yes, Silva was dominated by a journeyman fighter, a good journeyman, but a journeyman nonetheless.
I bet GSP takes the fight now that he sees what a wrestler can do to Silva, which wasn't much of a surprise if you had seen the fight with Chonan.
A journeyman that beat Nate Marquadt and Yushin Okami. Top 3 contender IMO.
No doubt, GSP #1 p4p
AnotherTMAguy -Ansari -AnotherTMAguy -Ansari -AnotherTMAguy - Has he beaten anyone at 185?
Anderson Silva P4P #1.
What does that have to do with P4P? I didn't ask where he ranked at 185.
I would say Anderson beating top 5 opponents in 2 weight divisions is more impressive than GSP beating top 5 opponents in 1 weight division.
P4P is an evaluation of fighters when taking weight of the equation. Try again.
Taking weight out of the equation is more accurate when a fighter can dominate fighters in 2 weight divisions as opposed to one weight division. Try again.
There you go talking about weight again. Try to argue P4P without making reference to weight in any way shape or form and you'll make more sense.
Absolutely.
Anderson has not faced a good MMA wrestler since his days in PRIDE.
Again, Henderson doesn't count. He hasn't shot a takedown since 2003.
NailedtotheSky - Easily, not even close. Chael impressed the hell out of me tonight, but should have posed about the same threat to Silva as maybe a a fighter like Hardy would to GSP.
GSP wouldn't have lost a round 10-8 to a journeyman.
GSP got KTFO and lost his title to a journeyman, meanwhile Anderson is still undefeated in the UFC.
eljamaiquino -NailedtotheSky - Easily, not even close. Chael impressed the hell out of me tonight, but should have posed about the same threat to Silva as maybe a a fighter like Hardy would to GSP.
GSP wouldn't have lost a round 10-8 to a journeyman.
GSP got KTFO and lost his title to a journeyman, meanwhile Anderson is still undefeated in the UFC.
Who he destroyed in the rematch
José Aldo :DDD