Frankie never held a title after the age of 30 despite the fact he had the option to pursue one at LW, FW or BW and he made an attempt and failed at FW and went 1-3 at BW and some feel he was really 0-4 at BW.
Penn never held a title after the age of 31 and he was able to win titles at both LW and WW when younger.
Emmett is powerful but a bit one note which is why he was handled by both Yair and Topuria. Yair finished him tho. Was prob good for Topuria to get that 5 round experience tho.
Well I think even without the Islam KO people talking stats would have been doubting him but you are right that he looked great in that first Makhachev fight.
Knowing Volk was 35 with zero FLW’s through LW’s ever winning a UFC title at the age of 35+… it was not looking good for him to me.
Someone asked Dana at the post fight presser about his comment that Wand had been Pete Rose’d and would never be in the HOF after he ran from USADA. Dana said he didn’t even remember saying that.
On another note they should have put Shogun in with Wand.
BTW if he fights Ortega or Yair, the promotion will (rightly) milk that both the champion and challenger speak Spanish (Ortega is fluent). Would be huge for promoting in Spain.
Max is in the same position with Volk where Bobby Knuckles was with Izzy. However, both Volk and Izzy have now been dethroned while they remain strong contenders (Bobby Knuckles less so due to the comprehensive loss to the current champ to DDP).
Regarding his return, Volk is in a terrible position. As you said, 2 KO losses in 4 months is bad. Very bad. I am not convinced the concussion against IM was particularly serious but he was completely shut off by IT and he MUST take time off to let his head heal the best it can. When Hearns starched Duran, Manny Steward visited Duran’s dressing room after and told him to take a minimum of 12 months off after the KO or his chin would never be the same. However, that would make Volk at least 36 before he comes back and he simply would never beat IT anyway.
Volk’s best option right now is to retire or take a year off then fight and beat someone not too threatening then return back his family and riches. If he does anything else, he is simply going end up being beaten again by either a top contender or IT. It’s going to be hard for him to go from almost beating IM to thrashing Yair to then getting stopped quickly by both IM and IT. But that’s the sport. I hope he can find peace with what he has achieved and what else he has in his life.
Good analysis. Yeah it would be real hard for him to take a lot of time off especially since he was just of the mindset of winning the LW title and then being so active he could defend both titles at the same time and fight 4x a year. That was his stated goal. Thing is, he did almost beat Makhachev the first time.
I think there is a 0% chance Volk retires right now but hopefully he does take some time off and then yeah, a safer fight before another title shot would be good.