Wow who else thought Edgar won 50-45 or 49-46???

daba -
Ebe5 - How many times did Edgar take him Down to the opposite? How many times did Edgar drop Ben to the opposite? How many times did Edgar catch the kick and counter? Your definition of doing nothing is very vague. He caught the kick, so therefore anything he does after that is a counter/doing something. And correct me if I'm wrong but counters are huge in any sport. He threw multiple punches in bunches after those caught kicks. The first round he took ben down with those same caught kicks. And if catching those kicks really were nothing then why doesn't very fighter catch kicks and hold a opponent up if it's THAT easy? Because its not, Frankie was the man and read those kicks to a T!<br><br><br>Btw no one has disagreed with my previous post.<br><br>I haven't looked at the fight metric but don't get to fooled anybody else notice the retarded flick of a jab that Ben was throwing?<br><br>And for those just jumping on, I bet on Ben and won but I still believe I owe the other dude money. Frankie got that shit. But I did think Ben got the 3rd by a smudge. <img src="/images/phone/apple.png" alt="Phone Post" border="0" style="vertical-align:middle;"/>


they landed at about the same rate but the big difference was that benson landed way harder shots. as far as catching kicks go, who cares unless you counter with a big shot and make the guy pay. yeah it's impressive for him to catch the kicks but if you don't counter effectively it's pointless which is why benson kept throwing the kicks.

the first round benson smashed edgars eye. round two he smashed edgars nose. if you wanna discredit fight metric what about those leg kicks that edgar landed that did nothing to benson. benson fought exactly the same from start to finish. the guy was not hurt or even tired by round 5. on the other hand edgar was bullied for most of the fight.


You do not judge a fight on how much blood one guy has on his face Phone Post

I gave Frankie 1,4,5. 3 was close enough to be 10-10 or go to Doug Benson. Smashed face doesn't equal a loss. For example GSP vs. BJ I. Phone Post

Pride Never Died -
Anarkis - No. Henderson did more damage.

 So if you beat the shit out of me but I broke your nose with a huge up kick. I win?

The shit out of who? He landed 1 solid right on Henderson. I like both dudes and it was the correct decision. There's just not even any doubt. Are you even serious? Phone Post

Jill Laz - IMO Frankie won for sure you do not judge a fight by how much a guy bleeds or how bad his face looks,Plus you have to beat the belt. But it sure works out for UFC they no longer want a stagnant weight class they need to make $ off the classes. Look at GSP people are sick of seeing same old champ he defended to many times there is a big loss of interest in GSPs fights (before he got injured). They also have Jose Aldo dressed up and nowhere to go he beat everyone so far wouldn't it be great if Edgar lost 10lbs and fought him who wouldnt pay to see that or benson vs Pettis. I'm not saying they fixed the fight at all but it sure fits a good business plan to have Edgar lose and than entice him to go down a weight class (just theories :) Phone Post

Dude, Henderson clearly won that fight. C'mon son. Phone Post

Twenty47 -
Pride Never Died -
Anarkis - No. Henderson did more damage.

 So if you beat the shit out of me but I broke your nose with a huge up kick. I win?

Good luck with this one because all the bjj fairies on this site think tapping someone is beating their ass. Phone Post

Huh? Do you make sense to you? Henderson tooled him. Won the fight clearly and savaged Edgar's face and body.... Bjj fairy? Wut? Phone Post

i thought frankie won, how the hell was this different from what condit did to diaz, one fight the judges score on points , and sometimes they score damage, , mma community better fix the scoring system or get better judges, because its starting to become a problem, every fight

daba -
Ebe5 - How many times did Edgar take him Down to the opposite? How many times did Edgar drop Ben to the opposite? How many times did Edgar catch the kick and counter? Your definition of doing nothing is very vague. He caught the kick, so therefore anything he does after that is a counter/doing something. And correct me if I'm wrong but counters are huge in any sport. He threw multiple punches in bunches after those caught kicks. The first round he took ben down with those same caught kicks. And if catching those kicks really were nothing then why doesn't very fighter catch kicks and hold a opponent up if it's THAT easy? Because its not, Frankie was the man and read those kicks to a T!<br><br><br>Btw no one has disagreed with my previous post.<br><br>I haven't looked at the fight metric but don't get to fooled anybody else notice the retarded flick of a jab that Ben was throwing?<br><br>And for those just jumping on, I bet on Ben and won but I still believe I owe the other dude money. Frankie got that shit. But I did think Ben got the 3rd by a smudge. <img src="/images/phone/apple.png" alt="Phone Post" border="0" style="vertical-align:middle;"/>


they landed at about the same rate but the big difference was that benson landed way harder shots. as far as catching kicks go, who cares unless you counter with a big shot and make the guy pay. yeah it's impressive for him to catch the kicks but if you don't counter effectively it's pointless which is why benson kept throwing the kicks.

the first round benson smashed edgars eye. round two he smashed edgars nose. if you wanna discredit fight metric what about those leg kicks that edgar landed that did nothing to benson. benson fought exactly the same from start to finish. the guy was not hurt or even tired by round 5. on the other hand edgar was bullied for most of the fight.


Man are you crazy, he catched alot of kick but he did shit after? Even his corber told him to stop catching the leg and instead go for the counter. Phone Post

i hated watching him get robbed like that
i thought he won 50-45

Frankie lost because bendo has 10x more power than him and 1 of bens shoots is 100 of frankies Phone Post

MCchoke - i hated watching him get robbed like that
i thought he won 50-45

See!!!! Phone Post

 

I was rooting for Frankie, but thought that benson got the right decision in the end. Phone Post

TOAO - If u think.frankie won that u r dumb dude, bendo dominated edgar Phone Post

No it was actually a pretty close fight Phone Post

Ebe5 - I haven't looked at the fight metric...

And for those just jumping on, I bet on Ben and won but I still believe I owe the other dude money. Frankie got that shit. But I did think Ben got the 3rd by a smudge.


1. look at the fight metric

2. if you feel that strongly, give the dude his money

Maybe your right... Phone Post

time traveling 12er - It was kind of pathetic to see Frankie losing and resorting to pointless late round take downs that didn't do anything to cheap his way to a win.


+1

By the scoring criteria Frankie one. However it was clear to see who did the most damage. Yet another example of judging inconsistency. Phone Post

diggity -
Jill Laz - IMO Frankie won for sure you do not judge a fight by how much a guy bleeds or how bad his face looks,Plus you have to beat the belt. But it sure works out for UFC they no longer want a stagnant weight class they need to make $ off the classes. Look at GSP people are sick of seeing same old champ he defended to many times there is a big loss of interest in GSPs fights (before he got injured). They also have Jose Aldo dressed up and nowhere to go he beat everyone so far wouldn't it be great if Edgar lost 10lbs and fought him who wouldnt pay to see that or benson vs Pettis. I'm not saying they fixed the fight at all but it sure fits a good business plan to have Edgar lose and than entice him to go down a weight class (just theories :) Phone Post

Dude, Henderson clearly won that fight. C'mon son. Phone Post

I really have to watch it again without emotion. I totally see that benson was stronger that's a fact look at Frankie's face but, I thought once Frankie caught a kick he got in points. You know how it is sometimes you view a fight without really seeing it, you may be right we'll see. Oh by the way I'm a chick not a dude lol :) I'm still learning but I have been watching for years I never miss a fight (I'm going to 145 ;) Phone Post

Jill Laz -
diggity -
Jill Laz - IMO Frankie won for sure you do not judge a fight by how much a guy bleeds or how bad his face looks,Plus you have to beat the belt. But it sure works out for UFC they no longer want a stagnant weight class they need to make $ off the classes. Look at GSP people are sick of seeing same old champ he defended to many times there is a big loss of interest in GSPs fights (before he got injured). They also have Jose Aldo dressed up and nowhere to go he beat everyone so far wouldn't it be great if Edgar lost 10lbs and fought him who wouldnt pay to see that or benson vs Pettis. I'm not saying they fixed the fight at all but it sure fits a good business plan to have Edgar lose and than entice him to go down a weight class (just theories :) Phone Post

Dude, Henderson clearly won that fight. C'mon son. Phone Post

I really have to watch it again without emotion. I totally see that benson was stronger that's a fact look at Frankie's face but, I thought once Frankie caught a kick he got in points. You know how it is sometimes you view a fight without really seeing it, you may be right we'll see. Oh by the way I'm a chick not a dude lol :) I'm still learning but I have been watching for years I never miss a fight (I'm going to 145 ;) Phone Post

If you kick a dude and he catches it, one dude got a power kick to the body, and one dude got his leg held and balance impeded for a second. Who would you rather be? Phone Post

 I am totally amazed at the amount of DEEEERRRRP! on this thread. Anyone thinking Frankie won all 5 rounds is a moran.